
Property investor Ben Nobelius has no plans to buy into the residential market again. After Labor’s changes to tax concessions, he can’t make it stack up financially. Add to that, he worries that more policy changes may yet be in the pipeline.
“You’ve got to put in hundreds of dollars a week just to top up the outgoing costs, finance and property management, and then you take all the risk as the investor and the landlord,” said the Melbourne-based investor who owns several properties and works as a land surveyor.
This week interest rates leapt to an 18-year high after the Reserve Bank lifted the cash rate to 4.85 per cent. As higher borrowing costs crimp demand, Commonwealth Bank economists this week said they now expect the housing market to record its largest downturn ever, with prices plunging in every capital city, including Sydney, where they will fall as much as 16 per cent.
While the CBA noted the impact of interest rate rises on the housing market, Reserve Bank of Australia governor Michele Bullock singled out the role Labor’s winding back of negative gearing and capital gains tax discounts in the May budget had played in the decline of investor loans.
“The fact that investors have declined so much further than it has in previous interest rate increasing cycles suggests that there’s something else going on here, and the something else going on is the tax changes,” Bullock said.
While prospects of a further interest rate rise have eased somewhat, it may be too late for property investors. Analysts and real estate agents fear they may be gone for good as a result of the tax changes, with some warning the reduction of that investment will cause rents to rise in the longer term.
For Nobelius, the significant policy changes in the last six months have left him thinking, ‘what’s next?’.
“As an investor and a developer, that’s always what you’re trying to manage is your risk. The risk right now feels like it’s coming just as strong from policy and government than anywhere else.”
New housing loan commitments are 27 per cent below their peak in November 2025, a decline that is larger than that experienced in most credit tightening phases since 1990, according to the RBA.
HSBC’s chief economist Paul Bloxham said the property downturn was the result of a double whammy from the structural change in the tax system coupled with a cyclical slowdown in the housing market.
“The cyclical story will start to turn the other way at some point down the track, but the structural change is persistent and so that will leave you with less investor interest overall,” Bloxham said.
The latest interest rate increase will take average variable mortgage rates to 6.75 per cent, and means repayments will consume 37.4 per cent of a typical household’s income – just shy of the record 37.5 per cent level reached in December 1989, according to analysis by REA Group.
Ray White chief executive of performance and value Thomas McGlynn said investors would usually be buying at this point in a downturn cycle as there are good opportunities but they are being held back by other factors.
“Investors on the ground haven’t necessarily lost confidence in property; they’ve lost confidence in the up and down nature of the environment that they have to stick to,” McGlynn said.
He said all the costs associated with owning property have become more expensive, while tax reform and interest rates are uncertain.
“Once upon a time, property was almost a safe haven for investors. It was something that was very predictable. I think everything that we’ve seen happening this year has changed that,” McGlynn said.
Property Investors Council of Australia president Tim Graham said it was difficult to see investors returning to the property market.
“Our concern really is what happens next. Australia already has a structural housing shortage,” Graham said.
“We’ve been calling for sensible CGT reforms that discourage speculators [short-term investors] in the market. We’d like the government to really reassess the reforms against their actual effects on housing investment, rental affordability, and the supply.”

